I had written before the Midterm Election that Michigan’s Senate race was Mike Rogers’ to lose. He proved he was certainly up to the task.

Rogers made a number of missteps. One of the worst was that he leaned into implying that his supporters are racist and that voters should vote for him out of fear of the “other.”
He also trampled on freedom of religion.
Never imply your voters are racist in any form
The vast majority of people do not view themselves as racist and bristle when someone implies that they are. Here, there was Islamophobia and racism at work at the same time. A fundamental issue Rogers should never have touched on was Abdul El-Sayed’s faith or the “Muslim danger.”
Doing so telegraphs that Rogers thinks his voters are racist and will respond well to this.
This is different from calling someone a communist. Most people indeed do view themselves as capitalists and are in fact anti-communist. Communism isn’t something we seek to protect. Particularly in rural areas.
Leaning into El-Sayed’s faith simply backfired. I also don’t think that Rogers really grasped the difference between being Muslim and Islamism.
I find that if someone wants to be racist, they can figure out how to do that all on their own.
Threatening the Freedom of Religion is a non-starter in rural areas
Rural voters, who also tend to have more religious education than urban voters, have a basic understanding of the difference between being Muslim versus someone promoting Islamism.
The number of comments defending El-Sayed that I have overheard on this issue since the election surprised me.
I have heard very cogent discussions of how the Qur’an (which I have read) can be problematic, such as the codification of slavery and the explicit permission for a master to have sexual relations with female slaves.
And that The Messenger of Allah (the “Prophet Muhammad”) himself owned around 40 slaves, at least 10 of whom were women.
In the Arab world, slavery was deeply integrated into Ottoman society and law. It was due to pressure from the British, among other Western powers, that the Arab world slowly gave up official slavery.
It doesn’t help that Saudi Arabia recently sentenced a poor female migrant worker to 100 lashes and banishment for having a child out of wedlock.
No one tried to locate or prosecute the father.
Yet numerous rural voters have been quick to defend El-Sayed as a Muslim and practicing the Muslim faith.
Which is different from Islamism.
It was a rural voter who pointed out to me that Thomas Jefferson wrote that our Constitution’s Freedom of Religion amendment was intended to protect individuals of all faiths and backgrounds, including Jews, Gentiles, Christians, Muslims, Hindus, and infidels.
Rogers and his allies should have remained above the fray. Instead, he victimized his opponent.
And trampled the First Amendment.
Rogers spent very little time on his own message
El-Sayed had a very clear message, even if most of it was platitudes. Rogers did not. I have yet to meet a voter who could tell me what Rogers stood for.
He did spend time trying to distance himself from President Trump. As well as spending a lot of time supporting Israel.
In the end, Rogers looked desperate. And forced to rely on his voters’ supposed bias to get him elected. While at the same time making El-Sayed a victim.
Not a terrific game plan.
And that’s why he lost by a large margin.







