Coal communities in Postindustrial America are getting older and smaller. But we can reimagine these places with the help of locals and new arrivals.

[Editor’s Note: James Branscome is the author of Annihilating The Hillbilly Redux: Appalachia’s Struggle Against America’s Institutions, a “profoundly important book for the field of Appalachian studies that shares the author’s personal experiences, his insights, and evidence-based understanding of the ways and means by which the Appalachian Region has been historically exploited.”]
For five years I have tracked births, deaths and migration in the 60 counties of the Central Appalachian Coalfields. Those numbers told me the region was shrinking. They did not tell me who was left.
The Census Bureau’s county estimates by age and sex do. I ran them for the same 60 counties in Kentucky, West Virginia, Virginia, and Tennessee, comparing the 2020 base with the estimate for July 2025 using Claude AI. The 60 counties are home to about 1.7 million people.
Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
The headline is simple. In 2020, the coalfields had about as many children as people 65 and older. By 2025 they had 112 seniors for every 100 children.
The nubmer of children under 18 fell by about 20,000, or 5.5%. Residents 65 and over rose by about 26,000, or 7.3%. In 2020, seniors outnumbered children in 24 of the 60 counties. Now they do in 39.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 county estimates by age and sex.
The biggest loss was in the middle
The group that shrank most was not the young. It was people 45 to 64, down more than 42,000, or 8.8%.
Many of them simply turned 65. That is the baby boom moving through. But it also means the coalfields are losing the generation that runs the small businesses, coaches the teams, sits on the school boards and looks after aging parents. There are fewer people behind them to take their place.
Young adults 25 to 44 held nearly even, down 1.2% across the region. So did women 20 to 39, the group that will decide how many children are born here over the next 20 years. That surprised me. It is the most hopeful number in the set.
It is also uneven. In West Virginia’s 16 counties, adults 25 to 44 fell 5.8%, and children fell 8.%. In Mingo County, the young-adult group dropped 15% in five years. In McDowell County, the number of children dropped 14.5%.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 county estimates by age and sex.
What Tennessee tells us
Tennessee’s seven counties again stand apart. They gained people, and they gained them at both ends. Adults 25 to 44 rose 12%. So did residents 65 and over. The number of children rose a little.
Part of that is Cumberland County, where the retirement communities around Crossville have pushed the median age to almost 55. It has more than two seniors for every child. Part of it is Anderson County, next to Knoxville and Oak Ridge, where young adults grew by 16%.
The lesson is the one I drew in “One Mountain Over” for Cardinal News. People will move to the mountains when there is work within reach and a place they want to live. Migration can bring young families as well as retirees. It does not happen by accident.
The Homestead Bridge, revisited
In “Will They Stay?” I proposed a Homestead Bridge. It would give a family land and housing help worth about $40,000 and a stipend of $1,500 a month for three years, stepping down over the next two. The full package comes to about $120,000 a household.
It works alongside the Appalachian Homestead Act laid out in my free guide, Changing the Names on the Deeds. The Act would buy land from bankrupt and distressed coal and timber owners and place it with current residents first, returning natives second and committed newcomers third.
The age data argue for three changes.
First, aim the Bridge at families with children. The young adults are still here. Their children are leaving faster than they are. Every family that stays keeps a classroom open.
Second, make room for halfbacks. The biggest loss is people in their late 40s to early 60s. Many who left in the 1980s and 1990s are now that age. Some have pensions, savings or remote work, and some want to come home. They are no substitute for young families, but they are the people who start small businesses and look after the old. The Bridge should offer them land and housing help even if they don’t need the full stipend.
Third, count by age. Any demonstration should report who enrolls by age and household, and whether their children stay in school here. My stayers-and-leavers analysis showed that the people who stayed paid a price in income. The question now is whether a bridge changes who stays.
An Ascend for the coalfields
Ascend West Virginia shows that paying people to come can work. It offers remote workers $12,000 over two years, along with free outdoor recreation and a network of local mentors. Program officials say it has brought more than 1,400 new residents to the state and that 96% of participants stay.
Ascend has reached the edges of my 60 counties. Its communities include the Greenbrier Valley, the New River Gorge and, since September 2025, Charleston and Kanawha County. It has not reached McDowell, Mingo, Logan, Wyoming or Boone, the southern counties losing young adults fastest.
Ascend participants earn about $100,000 a year on average, and they bring their jobs with them. That is both its strength and its limit. An Ascend for the coalfields would recruit remote workers to towns like Welch, Williamson and Logan. The Homestead Bridge would serve the families who don’t have that kind of paycheck.
West Virginia’s leaders should carry Ascend into the southern coalfields. Kentucky and Virginia could build versions of their own.
Harlan and Buchanan Counties
I have asked Gov. Andy Beshear and Gov. Abigail Spanberger to begin with a demonstration in Harlan County, Kentucky, and Buchanan County, Virginia. A first class of 100 to 250 households, chosen by lottery after a demand study, would cost about $12 million to $30 million.
The new data show why those two counties make a good test. They are losing people in different ways.
Harlan still has more children than seniors, about 90 seniors for every 100 children. But it is losing its young adults fast. Adults 25 to 44 fell almost 9% in five years, and women 20 to 39 fell 8%. Harlan would test whether a bridge can keep families from leaving.
Buchanan is further along. It has 146 seniors for every 100 children, and its median age is past 47. The number of children fell 11% in five years, and adults 45 to 64 fell 19%. Buchanan would test whether a bridge can bring families back.
Beshear’s term ends in December 2027, so a Kentucky start has to come soon. Spanberger has until 2030.
The clock is the age structure
A county with more children than seniors can still grow its way back.
A county with one and a half seniors for every child has fewer parents each year, and the climb gets steeper with each year we wait.
Thirty-nine of the 60 counties have already crossed that line. Harlan has not. That is a reason to start there, and to start now.
The coalfields powered the country for a century. A bridge home is a small payment on that debt.







